Press "Enter" to skip to content

PS Demands Walking Trail Revenue Transparency

PS-Madeira is calling on the Regional Government to disclose the revenue generated by the walking route fees and how the money is spent.

The party says that greater transparency is needed ahead of next year’s increases, arguing that the Government has provided no clear justification for the higher charges or evidence of corresponding investment in trail improvements. As part of the debate on the 2027 Regional Budget, the Socialist parliamentary group will propose a provision requiring the Government to explain the fees and publish details of revenue and expenditure.

PS deputy Sílvia Silva said the aim was to ensure accountability to Madeira’s population and dispel suspicions that money collected from mountain walks was being used to plug gaps elsewhere in the Government’s finances.

Under the proposal, the Institute of Forests and Nature Conservation (IFCN) would publish the technical and financial criteria used to set fees for each route. It would also regularly disclose revenue by route and ticket type, alongside a detailed breakdown of spending on maintenance, restoration, monitoring, safety and environmental conservation.

The Socialists say they have consistently supported charging tourists under the user-pays principle, with the proceeds helping to reduce tourism’s impact on natural heritage and ease pressure on public infrastructure. The party recalls proposing changes to walking route legislation in 2022 to regulate access according to visitor capacity and secure funding for maintenance and restoration. According to the PS, the PSD rejected that proposal.

Silva accused the governing parties of inconsistency, saying the PSD and CDS initially opposed access fees and favoured a less transparent donations system, which she said remained in place until July 2025. She also criticised Regional Government President Miguel Albuquerque’s approach, recalling his earlier comment that it was “better to have high levels of tourism and some accidents than not to have tourists.” She contrasted this with his more recent response to criticism of higher fees, saying those unwilling to pay need not come.

According to Silva, the Government changed its position in 2024 and turned the trails into a “money-making machine,” without delivering corresponding benefits for visitors or residents. She argued that Madeirans had instead faced restrictions on access to their own island’s countryside.

The deputy said visitors continued to report rubbish, a lack of toilets, overcrowding on certain sections, inadequate information and shortcomings in safety and enforcement. She also questioned whether fees and access rules were being applied consistently.

Against this background, Silva criticised proposed increases of between 67% and 233% on the most popular routes, with charges reaching €18 at Pico do Areeiro.

“The problem is not a lack of money; it is a lack of capacity to manage our natural heritage,” she said. She further argued that stronger enforcement to ensure all tourists using the routes paid the required fees could increase revenue without further ticket price rises. Maintaining, that higher charges had failed to deliver a better experience or improved safety, adding that rubbish remained on the trails despite the waste fee paid by users.

“The PSD has found a goldmine in tourist taxes, but greed without vision will exhaust the mine,” she warned.

Samantha Gannon

info at madeira-weekly.com

Views: 10

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes.
Madeira Weekly